Recipe: Cheese & Potato Pierogi

At any given moment I’m an arm’s reach from my cellphone. It’s not just a phone, it’s a laptop, a GPS, and – when my daughter tells it “I love you” – a female voice replies with almost lifelike bashfulness “You are sweet.”  Frankly, I’m frightened.

That’s why, when I receive mail – real mail, bundled up in cardboard and clear packing tape – I get so excited. Cardboard boxes don’t talk back. The postage stamp doesn’t double as a GPS when I’m fifteen minutes late for a show. It simply sits there, until I open it. The best possible mystery. The way it should be.

This week, Global Table Adventure received a package from my mom which tickled my funny bone in the most delightful way. This is reason #3,568,999 why my mom is so special. Ava, who was  as curious as I was, tore out the sheets of crinkly tissue paper to reveal a heavy duty heart-shaped bowl, small pitcher, and a covered sugar bowl. The bottom of each bowl read “Handmade in Poland.” Mom found them at a rummage sale, just in time for our feast.

I instantly knew the heart bowl was the perfect hug-shape for a stack of butter and onion-fried Peirogi. These central and eastern European dumplings are stuffed with anything from potatoes and cheese to sauerkraut or even prunes (the prunes being a sweet, dessert-style peirogi). These little bundles of comfort are so popular, you can even find them in American supermarkets. I’ve purchased them many times myself. Our version uses some cheddar, but for even more authenticity go for straight farmer’s cheese.

Still, despite the convenience, I wanted to try my hand at making them. We’re living in the rise of the cellphone “friend.” It’s time to push up our sleeves, slow down, and roll out some dough with our children.

Now, there’s a famous Polish saying “Piękna miska jeść nie daje,” which means a beautifully decorated plate won’t feed anyone.

I’m not so sure. Because, sometimes the plate inspires me to make something special to put in it.

Adapted from The Best International Recipe.

Serves 2-4



2 cups flour
1/2 tsp salt
2 eggs
1 Tbsp vegetable oil
4-5 Tbsp water, or as needed to bring the dough together.


1/3 cup onion caramelized in 2 tbsp butter (about 1 onion, plus more for serving, if desired)
1 medium russet potato, boiled then skinned
1/3 cup shredded cheddar
1/3 cup farmers cheese

4 Tbsp butter, for frying pierogi


Sometimes it’s not what’s on the outside, but what’s on the inside. This is as true of the humble Pierogi as it is of you, me, and certain Polish “hills.”

Just look at this mysterious architecture. Stunning. At least there are windows.

Twierdza Srebrna Góra. Photo by Ksiestwo.

Find a special kitchen spot and get to work… Boil and skin a russet potato, then mash with the cheesy, oniony goodness. Don’t forget the salt and pepper. Cover and refrigerate until cool.  (Once the filling is chilled, it will be firmer and easier to work with).

Meanwhile, prepare the dough by pulsing everything together in a food processor, or by mixing by hand in a bowl. Stream in just enough water to get it to pull together into a soft, workable dough. Wrap in saran and let rest about thirty minutes. This will let the gluten relax and make the dough easier to work with.

While it’s resting, go dance a little dance. Polish, preferably.

Traditional Polish Dancing. Photo by Nevit Dilmen.

Once you’ve danced enough to work up a sturdy kind of hunger… cut circles and top with a dollop of potato filling.

Pull the dough around the filling and pinch together at the top, then work around the edges. You might find it easier to work with less filling at first, but try to gradually work up to nice, plump pierogi. The dough should be elastic enough to do so.

You can either freeze them or boil right away. Simply cook until floating and the dough is cooked through – this only took about 3-5 minutes for me, but will depend on how thick your roll out your dough. Drain and brown in butter. You might also enjoy with caramelized onions or even a dollop of sour cream.

Trying new foods… it’s a process.

Sending you much love today, and always.


Opt In Image
Hungry for more?
Be notified when National Geographic releases my memoir.

Simply fill in your details below.


  1. I just happened across your site by way of Pioneer Woman. This post makes me want to put on a big read skirt, dance a little, and make some perogis! Thanks for the great post!

  2. So close yet so far! The business of our lives, can’t believe we haven’t had a chance to meet up, least I connect by looking at your site.

  3. I need to try making pierogies once in my life.

  4. This might very well be my favorite post of yours!!!! Awesome! The photos, recipe, everything! And, I have the exact same dish, except that it’s not heart-shaped, but it’s the same size and pattern. It is oval shaped. I love it.

    pierogi are the most delicious food ever, and I wish I had the opportunity to make it from scratch following your virtual lead. It will have to wait, but… I am pinning it! ;-)

    it’s a good thing cuteness doesn’t pay taxes or your daughter would make you and your husband go broke!

    • Sasha Martin says:

      Oh, you are so kind Sally :) Thanks for the words and the pin… as for Miss Ava – she cracks me up with her expressions. To be a child again…

  5. Aww, moms are the best! Your pierogi look amazing — just like the ones my grandma, mom, and aunts make every year for Christmas. It’s been a family tradition for as long as I remember for them to get together and assemble dozens of pierogi, some filled with cheese and potato and some filled with sauerkraut. They’re amazing. My grandma used to also make extra dough, because leftover dough can be cut into little chunks and boiled. Served with butter, they make the most delightful and comforting bowl of chewy noodles ever.

  6. Glad the pkge got to you in the nick of time….where’s the pitcher? Polishware costs a small fortune; however, it is so very durable….Neat blog…I am going to down-load for my half- Polish friend Edwina – who, by the way, uses prunes in all kinds of recipes….Thanks, Sash <3XO The Polish dancing is not as "stiff" as Hungarian…Hunkies wear boots…

  7. Those look amazing! I used to make pierogi all the time for my family before I went gluten-free (haven’t quite figured out a good gluten-free dough yet), but my favorite recipes always used sour cream in the dough… it seemed to help the texture.

    My favorite filling growing up was farmer’s cheese seasoned with salt and pepper. They were a favorite breakfast when fried in butter and topped with jam. Yum! If anybody is looking to buy authentic pierogi, Millie’s is the way to go- they’re so good!

  8. Pierogies are my daughter’s all-time favourite (in fact, we can usually convince her to try new foods by calling them something related – like dumplings are “dumpling pierogies”, and scalloped potatoes are “pierogy slices”). I’ve always used the frozen ones from the grocery, but if this is how easy they are, I may just have to try making them from scratch!

    • Sasha Martin says:

      I love this! I’m glad I’m not the only one who comes up with tricky ways to get my child to brave a new food haha.

  9. Cheddar in dumplings? Where does this idea come from? Never seen it and I’m Polish, live in Poland and regularly eat pierogi with potatoes and cheese (the white one called “twaróg”). You also use a complex type of dough, while busy Polish women just use flour and water. Nevertheless it’s interesting to see how Polish recipes look like in other countries. What’s more the potatoe-cheese pierogi are called “ruskie” – Russian :)

    I also love to see our traditional Polish pottery from Bolesławiec is quite popular in US. I love it too.

    • Sasha Martin says:

      Ola, it was adapted from The Best International Recipe – I’ll be sure to note that the farmer’s cheese is the more traditional, so they can go with 100% that instead. :) Thanks for your notes – it really helps with authenticity… I’m always seeking to learn the best approach.

  10. These look so good! I never considered making pierogi myself, but I think I could attempt this recipe! Somewhere I have some heart-shaped plates to serve them on… :)

    Can I ask what might be an obvious question – what is farmers cheese? I don’t live in the States, so what would I look for elsewhere? Thanks!

    • What she calls “farmers’ cheese” is called “twaróg” in Polish. I’ve never seen it in the US. It’s a wet, white cheese with a consistency between ricotta and cottage cheese, but with a different taste. After it’s been cooked to high temperatures, it loses its aftertaste, and can be used in many sweet dishes (sweet pierogi, crepes, cheescake, etc.).
      I’m not sure whether you can find it in your country, but perhaps you could try mixing different cheeses together til you find a combination you like. When I was in the US, I couldn’t find twaróg, so I made “pierogi American-style,” which involved corn, chicken, peas, cheese… basically whatever I wanted.
      You can make pierogi with any filling you want :)
      The dough here in Poland is usually made with just flour, water, and salt. It’s easier to work with I think, and cheaper to make :)
      Good luck!
      Rebeka in Poland

      • Sasha Martin says:

        Thanks Rebeka – I found farmer’s cheese at Whole Foods, actually – and it’s exactly as you say – a consistency between ricotta and cottage cheese. Very mild and wonderful!

      • I live in southeastern Pennsylvania and Farmers Cheese is widely available at farmers markets and grocery stores. I know Redners Markets for sure carries it. My father in law is Polish and they always make the pierogies with a cottage cheese and green onion filling.

  11. Your heart shaped bowl reminds me of the ceramics that we saw on a market in Jelenia Gora this summer ! We were told that it’s typical of a village specifically – Boleslawiec (thanks Ola). So great that your mom sent it just in time !

  12. Hello! :) I’m from Poland and pierogi it’s my taste of childhood. :) I love this polish dish, which is one of my favourite flour- made meals. You should also try ‘racuchy’. :) It’s something like frying, yeast pancakes – perfect with apples and caster sugar. Delicious <3 :)

  13. Nancy G. Parisi says:

    It makes my heart happy to see traditions carried on. My son, the chef, and family will be visiting soon, and his part-Polish wife requested that we make perogi. As the chef is 50% Polish, I figure we can muddle through together. I (100%, 2nd generation) have made perogi exactly twice in my ….hmmm…..years. I know my filling is good as I did make them for a couple of Polish exchange students a few years ago and they said they were like homemade. Our family used/uses diced onion, carmelized, sour cream and cottage cheese in the potatos, as well as a healthy amount of salt and pepper. We use a basic egg, flour, salt and water dough. The only negative comment was they were too big — about 4″ long.
    I also love the Bolslawiec Pottery and find it on occasion at Marshalls or TJ Maxx.

  14. Im not big fan of pierogi with cheese and potatoes, prefer with sour cabbage and mushrooms :) your look amazing and recipe is great. Btw all those beautifull plates are from Bolesławiec and they are very expensive.

  15. Chrystin says:

    I wanted to make pierogis for Easter this year and I cam across your recipe. They look delicious! Just one question: How did you get the brown color on the outside of the pierogis? Did you fry them after you boiled them? Thanks! Looking forward to trying them!

  16. Saw this on Pinterest, thanks for sharing!

  17. p.s, your little one is adorable!


  1. […] a surprise to Muffin, I made Pierogis for dinner last night. Not only are they simple to make, but they’re super yummy. They are a […]

  2. […] I’d be smiling, too, if I were dressed like this sweet pierogi! Can’t get a costume fast enough from Arla Designs? Try our homemade recipe for cheese and potato pierogi. […]

Speak Your Mind